Thrift vs. Vintage vs. Consignment: What's the Difference?

These words are often used as if they mean the same thing, but they describe different ways of running a shop. Knowing the difference helps you choose where to go and what to expect from the price.

Thrift stores

Thrift stores usually sell donated goods. Many are run by or raise money for charities, while others are for-profit businesses. Stock is broad and often cheap, but you'll need to do more searching.

Vintage shops

Vintage refers to older items, often at least 20 years old. An owner usually chooses each piece, so prices are higher and stock is more selective. You're paying partly for that expertise.

Consignment shops

Consignment shops sell items on behalf of their owners. The seller is normally paid a share of the price once the item sells. Quality and labels are usually a step up from thrift, and prices fall somewhere in between.

Buy-sell-trade stores

These shops buy clothing directly from the public, often paying right away or offering store credit. Stock tends to be recent and on trend. Buffalo Exchange, Crossroads and 2nd STREET are examples in Chicago.

Which should you choose?

• Tightest budget: thrift stores
• One-of-a-kind older pieces: vintage shops
• Designer labels for less: consignment shops
• Selling your clothes quickly: buy-sell-trade stores

You can filter by shop type in our directory.